Wednesday, 27 March 2013

The Last Cut is the Deepest

The thing that hurt most about this particular cut was that it was entirely self inflicted. While the concession of late goals from winning positions by our national team is not something that has arrived with Trap (think Macedonia under McCarthy, Israel under Kerr, Slovakia under Staunton), most of those turnarounds have come on the road and it was the manner in which we ceded the initiative and the inevitability of what transpired that was most galling. Make no mistake, those 2 points were lost last night by the managers stubbornness and ego, nothing more. While there were positives to be taken from the last weeks work, a 4 point haul was what the players deserved for their efforts but when help was needed from the sideline late on it wasn't forthcoming.

Again, the wisdom of naming the team 24 hours in advance has to be questioned. For right or wrong the selection of Conor Sammon up front for his first competitive cap was always going to be controversial and the resultant hoo ha in the media only served to increase pressure on the lad to perform. I appreciate that at 74 years of age Il Trap has his habits that he's not going to change now but I fail to see the benefit of giving the media an angle to run with. By all means let the players know the team but what advantage is gained from making it public, regardless of whether you think that it's a help to the opposition or not? Despite this and despite my pre match prediction that the game would end in a draw given our history of following up points gained away from home by dropping points at home I had my usual sense of pre match anticipation all day and my itchy feet finally got the better of me at 4.30 when I slipped out of work and made my way to meet the usual suspects in the Beggars Bush for some pre match lubrication. Although the scene on the walk down the canal through the snow was more reminiscent of a Christmas card than an Easter fixture the feel good factor from Fridays result was tangible and there was a great atmosphere around the Ballsbridge area as both sets of supported mixed freely swapping scarfs and exchanging chants. Word had filtered through of the commendable efforts of the You Boys in Green supporters group who, having heard of an Austrian couple who been pickpocketed the previous day and had their wallets and match tickets stolen, had arranged free tickets via the FAI and organised a collection to reimburse the money stolen with an excess being donated to charity. A number of Austrian fans mentioned this classy gesture which once again goes to show why we're the best supporters in the world and no doubt this contributed to the general air of bonhomie between the two sets of fans pre match.

With all the troops gathered we set off to the ground around 7.20 and instead of the usual mad rush actually made it into the ground comfortably for the national anthems and a lovely tribute to the late Con Martin, scorer of Ireland's first goal in that famous 2-0 victory v England in 1949 when we became the first foreign team to beat them on their home turf. Funnily enough I was actually wearing a replica of the shirt the team wore that day which provided a lot more warmth than todays kits would have! Having positioned ourselves on the far right of the Singing Section we started getting behind the team. I thought we made a decent start and, despite Austria having the first strike on goal from a free that went safely past the post, had the better of the early exchanges with Long being incorrectly called back for offside while going through on goal and McClean winning the first corners of the game. However, just as the game was settling down, disaster struck. Reminiscent of the error he made in the Premier League a few weeks ago against Man City and despite having plenty of time and options to clear the ball Ciaran Clark dawdled on it trying to beat two attackers, was dispossessed and before we got catch our breath the ball had been squared across the box to Harnick who gave Forde no chance. It was an absolute howler from Clark and there really is no excuse especially having been caught doing similar a matter of weeks ago. He needs to cut that out of his game, I have big hopes for him as a player for the future but you'd hope that his decision making improves with age.

Given how Ireland have capitulated after going behind in recent games it was encouraging to see the response here though. Ireland quickly regrouped and upped the tempo and began putting the Austrian goal under pressure with McClean and Long looking particularly lively. Having being denied a certain corner when Long played the ball out off his marker we regained possession and started causing then some problems at the back. Every time they cleared the ball was coming back and eventually Long got onto a ball over the top from Glen Whelan and despite looking short on options at the byline held the ball up till Pogatetz dived in with as reckless a challenge as anyone would have been seen all week. A stonewall penalty and despite having missed 3 in the league this season Jon Walters stepped up and buried it in the right hand corner! One all and game on. The atmosphere upped a notch and at this stage was probably the best it's been in the new Lansdowne bar the celebratory vibe of the deal rubber play off 2nd leg v Estonia. Buoyed by getting back on terms so quickly and feeding off the crowd Ireland really got into the ascendency with an audacious back heel from Shane Long hitting the inside of the post and somehow rebounding to safety. At this stage Sammon was winning his share of headers and rather than settle for going in level at half time we kept up the pressure and when Whelan swung in another corner that had been won by McClean in stoppage time, Jon Walters did superbly under pressure to get his head to it and guide it into the corner! Lansdowne erupted and there was a real sense of optimism returning with the debacle against Garment retreating further into the memory. Austria barely had time to kick off before the ref blew for half time.

So far so good and it was great to see the team come back from a self inflicted wound and take the game to the opposition in the manner they did. The half time chat was all about whether we'd start the second half in a similar manner or whether we'd retreat so there was a palpable sense of relief as we started aggressively again and McClean nearly capped off what had been a very impressive display with a free kick that hit the side netting. Little did we know misguided that relief was. While Austria gradually got a foothold in the game, it was ebbing and flowing as any match does and we responded well by having another spell of pressure resulting in a series of corners around the 70 minute mark. One of these nearly resulted in the third goal we craved which would surely have wrapped the game up when an Austrian defender under pressure from Sammon headed straight at his own goal only for the Austrian keeper to pull off an amazing save. The next corner also resulted in a decent chance for Marc Wilson who headed just wide and you could clearly see from our position behind the goal in the South Stand how rattled and how relieved to only be a goal down the Austrians were. At that stage they were there for the taking, all it needed was to use the bench. Sammon had run his legs to stumps by then and had he been taken off at thst stage would have been given an ovation for his work rate and endeavour. I think it was tailor made for Wes Hoolahan (indeed, I'd have started him) but if Trap didn't trust him to do the required job then Kevin Doyle was the obvious change to make. Instead it seemed like once we didn't score from that spell of pressure we decided to take what we had.  St Ledger replaced an injured Clark and we sat further and further back inviting the opposition on to us. Into the last 10 minutes and we were holding firm but again we were crying out for a change. Bizarrely, Long, who looked our freshest player up front and had had an excellent game gets replaced by Green with Walters moving up front alongside Sammon. Both players were looking leggy by then and when the ball was coming up field it wasn't sticking. With another sub in hand surely now was the time to use it. But no, rather than twisting Trap decided to stick as we got pinned back time and again. The time was moving tortuously slowly by then but when the board came up showing a fair 3 minutes I started to think we might get away with it. Indeed, in the first minute of stoppage time we won a free in the corner in their half. Surely then was the time to use the last sub, calm things down and play the ball into the corner to run down the clock. No, instead a rushed free kick saw Walters lose possession and we were back under the cosh. There was a horrible sense of inevitability as we cleared a couple of half chances but couldn't relieve the pressure. Sure enough as the game got close to the final minute of stoppage time and as we roared our defence on Albala takes a final pot shot that clips off an attempted block from St Ledger to loop into the net giving Forde no chance. The sense of deflation was as sharp and quick as someone bursting a balloon. The atmosphere was killed stone dead in a split second.

The second thing that hurts so much is that the feeling was oh so familiar. Regardless of the manager, over the years we never seem to have the minerals required to see the job out against our rivals in the qualifiers. We've conceded goals in the last minute against Croatia and Macedonia in Euro 2000. Israel in WC 2006, Slovakia and Wales in Euro 2008 and Italy in WC 2010. Goals in the last ten minutes v Turkey, Holland and Switzerland in the same time period. Even under Charlton during our 'glory years' we blew Eruo 92 qualification by conceding 2 late goals away to Poland and we were rarely able to win the home games against our nearest rivals, drew with Belgium and Scotland in 88, drew with England and Poland in 92, drew with Denmark and lost to Spain in 94, drew with Northern Ireland and lost to Austria in 96. Under McCarthy more of the same, drew with Romania, Iceland and Belgium in 98, drew with Turkey in 00, drew with Portugal in 02 and lost to Switzerland in the aftermath of Saipan before he resigned. Brian Kerr comes in and we draw with Russia in the 04 campaign and drew with France and Switzerland in 06. Stan comes in and we draw with Czech Republic, Cyprus and Germany in 08. And since Trap came we've drawn with Italy, Bulgaria and Montenegro and lost to France in the 2010 series and drew with Slovakia and lost to Russia in Euro 201 2. This is no new phenomenon but the chance was there to buck the trend last night. For a manager of his experience not to take advantage of the bench in the last 5 minutes or even in stoppage time was criminal. I feel that he wanted to prove a point about Sammon which is whey he left him on when he'd clearly run himself into the ground and needed to be replaced by fresh legs. A chance to say 'Trap knows best'. Well, it's rebounded on him big time and it's us, the supporters, who are feeling it more keenly then anyone.

So, in the cold light of day, where does this leave us? I don't think that changing the manager is viable at this point, I don't believe the FAI have the money to pay him off and, despite the nature of the draw last night, barring the aberration against Germany, the campaign is panning out like most of the campaigns have the last 30 years, including our successful ones. We've generally beaten the minnows under Trap and I don't see that changing. Austria and Sweden have to play each other twice so someone will drop points there, 2 draws would be the best outcome. We haven't lost an away qualifier under Trap but I think we'll need to turn that into a win in the return v Austria and we'll need to beat Sweden at home. Do that and we have a chance. It's possible but the fact that goal difference rather than head to head determines the position if teams are level on points puts us at a distinct disadvantage. One things for certain, any wriggle room we had disappeared with that flash of David Alaba's boot at 9.36 last night.


  1. Heartbreaking result ... good descriptions, Tony. Feel as if I was there myself instead of screaming at the television. All we can do is cross our fingers and hope we'll be singing Come On You Boys In Green in Brazil!

  2. I think your view of Sammon's performance was very generous. No blame attached to the player but despite trying hard he only won a small fraction of what you'd expect a player of his size to win.

    The game plan was hoofball from start to finish and if we did create chances it was down to sheer use of a bludgeon. There's no way to tell that if we had engaged them with more conviction and moral honesty - like we did in Stockhom - 0 if the outcome would be any different, but my guess is that we'd have beaten them. The team lacked a bit of savvy and leadership on the puitch but we pay Trapattoni handsomely to do the same from the sideline and he abdicated his responsibility.

    btw, I think Long was taken off because he was losing the head. Again, Trap or tradelli could have calmed him down. Instead we left a cooked Sammon on and moved walters upfront when Green should have made up a 5th midfielder, not a right-sided midfielder. Awful stuff from Trap.

  3. I think Sammon had an average game. I think the nnuisance value he provided gave Long a degree of space and freedom to be as effective as he was. I'd probably have given him a 6 although given how ineffective he was the last 15 minutes there's an argument to be made that that's generous. He was involved in the move for the pen, the move where Long hit the post and had the defender who nearly scored the og that would have sealed the game under pressure which a lot of people don't seem to be prepared to acknowledge. I feel many fans had Sammons performance determined before he set foot on the pitch, I wouldn't have him in the team but I've tried to be objective with him. Regarding Long, I feel you may be right and have said the same while discussing the game since. However, Trap said it was due to tiredness so I commented based on that. Given how Long reacted after not getting his free in charging into a ridiculous challenge straight after for his yellow there's certainly merit on that argument. On the other hand it was a useful booking to pick up given that he'll now only miss the faroes game and I feel he'd have been able to see our the last 7 minutes on.Tuesday.

    I disagree that it was hoofball from start to finish, most analysis I've seen from half time would agree that we played some good stuff and the build up to the chance off the post was superb. McClean regularly showed for and got on the ball. The one time when hoofball should have been employed Clark tried to play it out and got mugged. You can't let the last 20 minutes cloud your judgement of the 90.